Most retirement plans start with a target age, the point when your savings, investments, and Social Security benefits should be enough to replace a paycheck.
That target is usually 65 or later, and it shapes every contribution rate, coverage decision, and investment allocation made for decades in advance.
Data from Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America suggests that the target may rest on a flawed assumption for a significant share of the American workforce.
The insurer’s 2026 Annual Retirement Study found that 42% of retirees left the workforce earlier than planned.
Only 5% of retirees reported staying on the job longer than expected, which means the risk of an early departure dwarfs any chance of extra saving time. The reasons behind those premature exits look nothing like what active workers expect.
Health setbacks and job losses account for most unplanned early retirements
Health complications that prevented performing a job drove 30% of early retirements, making medical crises the single largest involuntary cause, the Allianz study found.
Unexpected job loss triggered another 21% of premature departures, while a separate 21% said they left because their savings had reached an adequate level early. For most of the 42% who departed ahead of schedule, the decision to retire was forced on them.
Active workers imagined a different set of reasons for a potential early exit, with 36% citing family time and 31% citing stress reduction as primary motivators, Allianz reported.
Craig Copeland, director of wealth benefits research at the Employee Benefit Research Institute, told PLANSPONSOR that saving more earlier can act as protection against the unknown.
Many people think they’ll be able to continue working, maybe not forever, but to an older age. Very few people get that opportunity to [follow] their exact plan,
Kelly LaVigne, vice president of consumer insights at Allianz Life, said in a statement that “when retirement comes early, it can quickly turn a solid plan into a fragile one.”
LaVigne added that “fewer working years and more retirement years can put significant pressure on savings, especially when early retirement isn’t a choice.”
Three national surveys expose a persistent retirement timing gap
Allianz Life’s 42% figure does not stand alone; two separate national surveys released in 2026 found equal or higher rates of involuntary early retirement across broader samples.
The Employee Benefit Research Institute’s 2026 Retirement Confidence Survey reported that 46% of retirees exited before their planned timeline.
Among those who retired ahead of schedule, 76% attributed their early departure to circumstances entirely outside their personal control, the survey indicated.
More Retirement:
Retirement Tech in 2026: AI, Operational Efficiency, and Better Participant Experience
George Kamel, Rachel Cruze warn about a mortgage retirement trap
Massachusetts retirement taxes explained: What retirees should know before moving or staying
The Society of Actuaries Research Institute’s 2024 Retirement Risk Survey, published in May 2026, put the early retirement figure even higher at 59% of all retirees surveyed.
Workers in the EBRI survey expected to retire at a median age of 65, while retirees reported an actual departure age closer to 62, a gap that has persisted since the late 1990s.
Nearly 40% of workers planned to keep working until at least 70, but only 10% of retirees reported careers that actually extended that far, EBRI found.
Three national surveys reveal a persistent retirement timing gap, with many Americans leaving work earlier than planned due to circumstances beyond their control.Olga Pankova / Getty Images
Lower-income retirees bear the steepest health-related retirement risks
The gap between plans and outcomes is widespread, but it is not evenly distributed. Income level decides how hard the hit from a forced early exit lands, shaping both who is most likely to be pushed out and how deep the financial damage runs.
Among retirees with under $35,000 in annual retirement income, 49% cited health as their primary reason for leaving early, the Society of Actuaries reported.
Job loss affected about 20% of early retirees regardless of earnings bracket, which means employer-driven displacement cuts across every income level, the survey confirmed.
Declining confidence among workers adds pressure to the timing risk
Eight in ten Americans surveyed by Allianz said they believe working longer would improve their retirement finances. Yet the data show that the option is frequently unavailable, a mismatch that is dragging confidence down.
Confidence in affording a comfortable retirement dropped six percentage points among active workers in 2026, falling to just 61%, according to the EBRI annual survey.
Retiree confidence also fell five points to 73%, as concerns about Social Security and Medicare stability weighed on financial outlooks across generations.
Nearly 60% of workers said healthcare costs are undermining their ability to save, and 65% identified outstanding personal debt as a significant barrier, EBRI reported.
Seven in ten retirees and 80% of workers expressed concern that government changes to the retirement system could eventually reduce their expected benefits.
What the 42% figure means for workers planning to work until 65
Workers who had no say in when they left absorb the worst of the timing gap: shorter contribution windows, longer drawdown periods, and reduced Social Security benefits.
EBRI’s data puts the actual median retirement age at 62. That three-year gap can cut Social Security benefits by up to 30%, a reduction that is permanent once benefits are claimed.
Workers who exit before 65 also lose employer-sponsored health coverage before Medicare eligibility begins. For someone forced out at 60 or 61, that gap stretches to four or five years of self-funded premiums without group rates or employer subsidies.
Related: Fidelity retirement rule fails in 1 of 10 scenarios