sturti / Getty Images
Student loans could become more prominent in paying for college if the United States Department of Education closes. Incoming-President Donald Trump promised to abolish the Education Department if elected, but federal student loan balances are unlikely to disappear. However, even if federal loans remain part of the higher education landscape, changes to the federal student loan program and the options available could lead to borrowers turning to private student loans in greater numbers.
Key Takeaways
- If President Trump fulfills his campaign promise to abolish the Department of Education, payments will likely be managed by other government agencies.
- Any new efforts for blanket student loan forgiveness are unlikely to emerge under the new administration.
- Changes to federal student loan borrowing and repayment options could lead to more families using private student loans to fund a higher education.
Trump’s Plan for the Education Department
While on the campaign trail, Trump repeatedly called for the end of the Department of Education. If congressional support emerges to shutter the department, trillions of dollars in federal student debt would still need to be managed. Trump has previously advocated for merging the Education Department with the U.S. Department of Labor.
Additionally, Trump would presumably sign the College Cost Reduction Act, an overhaul of several aspects of the federal student loan program. Introduced by House Representative Virginia Foxx (R-NC), this legislation proposes getting rid of PLUS loans and replacing the existing income-driven repayment (IDR) plans with a new “repayment assistance plan.” Under this new IDR plan, borrowers would qualify for forgiveness after paying an amount equal to the “principal and interest owed under the standard 10-year plan.”
Important
The Biden administration’s Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) plan is currently on hold due to several court actions. Borrowers enrolled in the plan have been placed in an interest-free forbearance until the matter is resolved.
Private vs. Federal Student Loans
Private student loans only accounted for about 7.61% of outstanding student debts, or $133.43 billion, in March 2024. Meanwhile, as of Q4’24, there’s approximately $1.64 trillion in outstanding federal student debt.
Federal and private student loans both have advantages and disadvantages, so each type can work well for different students (depending on their needs).
Federal Student Loans
-
No credit requirements for undergraduate loans
-
Relatively low borrowing limits, which might not cover the full cost of attendance
-
Fixed interest rate set by congressional formula and the same for each loan type
-
Variety of IDR plans and hardship options
-
No possibility of securing lower interest rates or avoiding origination fees
Private Student Loans
-
Credit inquiries required for all loans, including undergraduate
-
Ability to borrow sufficient funds to cover the entire cost of attendance
-
Fixed and variable rates determined by lender, market conditions, and/or borrower’s
-
Hardship options vary by lender
-
Some loans come without origination fees, and well-qualified borrowers could get lower interest rates
Source: Federal Student Aid
Generally, it’s best to start with federal student loans due to their fixed rates, lack of credit requirements, and multiple repayment options (including potential student debt forgiveness). However, private loans can be a good option if you still need to cover a funding gap after maxing out your federal student aid package. However, this dynamic could change if the Education Department disappears.
Even if the Department of Education remains intact, private loans could become a bigger part of the college funding picture should the College Cost Reduction Act become law. The proposed changes to federal student loans, including replacing IDR plans and eliminating PLUS loans, would limit the options available to borrowers, which may encourage more of them to take out private student loans.
The Bottom Line
Without the Department of Education, Federal loans may become less appealing to borrowers. While not necessarily likely, it’s possible federal government will stop originating new student loans altogether, leaving borrowers little choice but to turn to private lenders. Nothing has been decided yet, so borrowers—existing and new—must wait to see how the Trump administration deals with student debt.