Reviewed by Andy Smith
Fact checked by Hans Daniel Jasperson
Lump-Sum vs. Pension Payments: An Overview
Monthly pension payments are a fixed dollar amount. They begin at retirement and last until a retiree’s death. Some plans offer a survivor’s benefit for a living spouse. A lump sum distribution is a one-time cash disbursement at retirement. The retiree is solely responsible for managing the funds throughout their retirement years.
Those who are approaching retirement and who are eligible for a pension often weigh the choice between accepting the traditional, lifetime monthly payments or taking a lump-sum distribution.
Key Takeaways
- Pension payments are made for the remainder of a retiree’s life.
- Lump-sum distributions allow individuals to spend or invest the money.
- Those who take a lump sum might outlive their money.
- Pension payments can stop if a pension administrator goes bankrupt.
Lump-Sum Distributions
A lump-sum distribution is a one-time payment from a pension administrator. Individuals have access to a large sum of money that they can spend or invest.
A pension payment annuity is commonly a fixed payment but a lump sum offers flexibility. It may also provide regular income if it’s invested properly. Those who take a lump-sum distribution can name a beneficiary to receive any money that’s left after their deaths.
Income from pensions is taxable but individuals can roll over a lump sum into an IRA and control when to withdraw the funds and pay income tax. Retirees will eventually have to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) from their IRA but that won’t happen until age 73.
Note
Rolling a lump sum pension payment into an IRA lets individuals plan when they’ll take their distributions and when they’ll pay the associated taxes.
Pension Payments
A pension payment is a set monthly payment to a retiree for life and for the life of a surviving spouse in some cases. Some pensions include cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) so payments are indexed for inflation.
A regular pension check can help retirees budget and control overspending. Retirees with company health insurance may have to opt for pension payments because coverage might stop if an employee takes a lump sum.
Retirees with pension income were more likely to remain financially stable in 2020 than those who cashed out the lump sum, according to research from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Of those with regular payments, 73% could maintain the same spending level after five years compared to only 56% of those who had chosen the lump sum.
Important
Pension payments could stop if a pension administrator goes bankrupt but the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC), a federal agency, provides insurance that covers most people.
One threat to pensions is that an employer fails to pay long-term. However, pension benefits are safeguarded by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC), a government entity that collects insurance premiums from employers sponsoring insured pension plans. The PBGC only covers defined-benefit plans, not defined contribution plans like 401(k)s.
The maximum annual benefit was $85,295.40 in 2024 for a straight-life annuity for a 65-year-old retiree.
Key Differences
Lump Sum
-
All pension money is distributed at once at retirement
-
The retiree must manage the funds throughout retirement
-
Lump sum money can be rolled over into an IRA
-
Retirees can designate beneficiaries of the funds
Pension Payments
-
Payments are made monthly to the retiree until death
-
The PBGC provides insurance in case the pension administrator is unable to pay
-
Monthly payments may cease once the retiree dies unless there are survivor’s benefits
-
Companies may require retirees to take monthly payments to keep health insurance benefits
How Will I Use This in Real Life?
Planning for retirement can be a challenge because real life has a way of being unpredictable but the decision between taking a lump sum distribution or pension payments can come down to how well you know yourself.
That lump sum payment might not be the right choice for you if your risk tolerance is minimal and the thought of investing the money in the stock market gives you indigestion. You might consider a safer investment, however, or roll the money over into an IRA. Accepting a lump sum payment might be a disaster if spending freely and lavishly is your vice. You could deplete your retirement cushion if you treat it as an unexpected windfall.
Taking pension payments may be your best option if you value safe, steady income above all else, especially with the added benefit of PBGC insurance. And you may be able to keep your health insurance benefits if you continue taking your monthly payments.
It may help to make a checklist of all pertinent factors and organize them according to what’s most important to you.
How Do Companies Calculate Pension Payments and Lump Sum Distributions?
The typical recipient receives approximately the same amount of money whether choosing the pension or a lump sum. The pension administrator calculates the commuted value using the average lifespan of retirees and adjusts the payment schedule accordingly. Retirees with a longer-than-average lifespan will probably receive more money by taking lifetime payments.
What Are the Disadvantages of Taking a Lump Sum?
Taking a lump-sum payment can be very risky. Perhaps the greatest risk of cashing out a pension early is the prospect of running out of money. A monthly payment offers a steady income for the remainder of one’s life instead and it can also be passed on to a spouse in some cases. Retirees who choose a lump sum could put part of the money into a fixed annuity with the help of a financial advisor.
Is a Pension Plan the Same As a Defined Benefit Plan?
Yes, a private pension plan is a defined benefit plan where the employer makes most contributions on behalf of the employee toward their retirement.
The Bottom Line
A lump-sum pension payment makes sense for some. Having less upfront capital is better for others. Pension payments should align with a retiree’s personal goals in either case. A financial advisor can guide those who are considering whether to choose a monthly payment or invest a lump sum for the long term.